A comprehensive analysis of 130 million vehicle trips conducted throughout 2025 has unveiled a striking divergence in urban driving behavior across Europe, with the frequency of harsh driving events varying by more than five-fold between the continent’s major capital cities. According to the latest European Urban Freight Efficiency Index released by Geotab Inc., a global leader in telematics and connected transportation, the data suggests that geography, infrastructure design, and local traffic culture play a more significant role in road safety than previously understood.
The study, which utilized high-precision GPS telemetry to track instances of harsh acceleration, braking, and cornering, serves as a critical benchmark for fleet managers and urban planners. By monitoring the performance of Geotab-connected vehicles, the research provides an empirical look at how the physical fabric of a city dictates the movement of goods and people, offering a granular view of risk that transcends simple traffic volume statistics.
The Geography of Risk: A Tale of Two Extremes
The data paints a stark picture of urban volatility. Berlin emerged as the safest environment for professional drivers, recording a mere 225 harsh events per 1,000 trips. This equates to roughly one harsh maneuver every four to five trips. At the other end of the spectrum, Paris recorded a staggering 1,191 harsh events per 1,000 trips—a rate 5.3 times higher than that of the German capital. Madrid followed closely as the second-most volatile, logging 1,088 events per 1,000 trips.
The discrepancy between these figures is not merely a matter of total vehicle numbers; it is a reflection of how local infrastructure shapes driver behavior. In Berlin, the city’s polycentric layout and wide, straight boulevards facilitate a steady, predictable flow. Conversely, in cities like Paris and Madrid, the prevalence of dense, high-pressure traffic networks necessitates more aggressive driving maneuvers, leading to the high incidence of acceleration-heavy events.
Analytical Breakdown: Why Cities Differ
The index highlights that the nature of these harsh events—acceleration, braking, or cornering—serves as a diagnostic tool for fleet managers. By identifying the dominant type of driving incident, firms can tailor their interventions to specific local challenges.
In Paris and Madrid, where acceleration events dominate (accounting for 79% and 69% of all incidents, respectively), the data points to a culture of rapid, stop-and-go movement, likely driven by dense intersection networks and impatient traffic flows. In these cities, the primary solution for fleet operators lies in driver coaching and the implementation of in-cab feedback systems designed to encourage smoother, more fuel-efficient acceleration.
In contrast, cities like Amsterdam and Rome exhibit a higher frequency of harsh cornering. Amsterdam, characterized by its intricate canal-side grid and narrow, bridge-heavy infrastructure, sees 34% of its incidents attributed to cornering—the highest in the study. Rome, with its historic, irregular street layout, follows a similar pattern. For fleets in these cities, the issue is not necessarily the temperament of the driver, but the physical limitations of the road network. In these environments, route optimization and the use of specialized navigation software are far more effective than individual driver training.
Infrastructure Bottlenecks and Spatial Concentration
The study also identified significant variations in how these incidents are distributed geographically within each city. Amsterdam, despite being a smaller market in terms of total area, exhibits a high level of concentration. Approximately 13.7% of its total harsh driving events occur within three specific zones near the A4 approach to Schiphol Airport. This suggests that the geometry of that specific interchange is a primary driver of risk, and that a single infrastructure project or a change in routing policy could yield significant safety dividends.
Dublin presents a similar, albeit more linear, challenge. The Naas Road (N7) corridor serves as a major bottleneck, containing the city’s three busiest accident hotspots. In these areas, the high rate of harsh cornering—often exceeding 70% of all local incidents—strongly correlates with complex roundabouts and merge points.
London, meanwhile, presents a unique case study. Despite ranking low in overall efficiency with a score of 29, its harsh event rate is spread remarkably thin across its vast network. No single area in London accounts for more than 0.6% of the city’s total incidents. This lack of a "single point of failure" suggests that London’s congestion charging, signal management, and strict enforcement have created a relatively uniform, albeit slow, traffic environment.
Implications for Fleet Management and Safety
The findings of the 2025 Geotab index are expected to shift the paradigm for fleet operations in Europe. For decades, fleet managers have often applied universal safety KPIs across their entire international workforce. However, this study suggests that such "one-size-fits-all" metrics are fundamentally flawed.
"A harsh event rate only means something when you know which city the driver is working in," noted Edward Kulperger, senior vice president for EMEA at Geotab. "The same number can be an average day in Madrid and a warning sign in Berlin."
This shift in perspective is critical for risk management. By benchmarking drivers against local averages rather than global standards, companies can move away from punitive management styles toward data-driven support. If a driver in Berlin logs 1,000 events, they are a clear outlier requiring intervention. The same driver in Paris is simply following the local trend.
Broader Urban Planning Consequences
Beyond the scope of individual fleet management, the data offers valuable insights for municipal authorities. By mapping where and why harsh events occur, cities can identify "hidden" safety risks that might not show up in traditional accident reports—which often only capture high-impact collisions.
For instance, the high concentration of incidents in Dublin’s N7 corridor or Amsterdam’s airport interchange suggests that minor infrastructure modifications—such as better lane markings, improved signage, or the redesign of turning radii—could significantly lower the frequency of harsh braking and cornering. As cities move toward more sustainable and electrified logistics fleets, the efficiency gains from smoother, more consistent traffic flows will become increasingly vital for both operational costs and the reduction of urban emissions.
Chronology and Methodology
The 2025 analysis was conducted throughout the calendar year, capturing seasonal fluctuations and peak-hour variations across the seven capitals. Data collection was centralized through the Geotab platform, which monitors engine data, GPS location, and accelerometer readings in real-time.
The study observed that incident rates do not necessarily correlate with total traffic volume. While Madrid experienced high pressure throughout the day, with significant event counts even at 05:00, other cities like Paris showed clear peak-hour spikes, particularly around 19:00. This variance highlights that "efficiency" is not merely about congestion, but about the quality of the driving experience and the predictability of the road network.
Conclusion: Data as a Catalyst for Change
As European cities continue to face the pressures of rapid urbanization and the growing demand for last-mile delivery, the role of data in ensuring safe and efficient transport becomes paramount. The Geotab European Urban Freight Efficiency Index provides a clear roadmap for stakeholders to transition from reactive safety measures to proactive, data-led strategies.
Whether through individual driver coaching in Paris to reduce aggressive acceleration, or through tactical routing adjustments in Dublin and Amsterdam to avoid dangerous junctions, the path forward is clear: data transparency and localized benchmarking are the keys to a safer, more efficient urban future. The findings underscore that while the driver is often the focus of safety initiatives, the city itself—with its design, history, and flow—remains the most influential factor in determining the outcome of every trip.



