Home Digital Banking & Neobanks ABA comments on merchant groups’ lawsuits against OCC, NCUA | ABA Banking Journal

ABA comments on merchant groups’ lawsuits against OCC, NCUA | ABA Banking Journal

by Jia Lissa

The Genesis of the Illinois Interchange Fee Prohibition Act

The conflict originated in 2024 when the state of Illinois enacted the Interchange Fee Prohibition Act (IFPA). The legislation was framed by its proponents—primarily retail and merchant interest groups—as a necessary correction to perceived inequities in the electronic payment system. Specifically, the IFPA sought to prohibit banks and payment networks from collecting interchange fees on the portions of a debit or credit card transaction that accounted for state or local taxes and tips.

From the perspective of merchant trade associations, the law was intended to lower the cost of doing business, arguing that processing fees on tax and gratuity amounts represented a "tax on a tax" or an unfair surcharge on voluntary employee compensation. However, the financial services sector immediately identified the act as a dangerous intrusion into the federal oversight of the national payment infrastructure. They argued that because the payment system is a highly integrated, national network, allowing individual states to carve out exemptions for specific transaction components would create a logistical nightmare for issuers, merchants, and the networks that facilitate trillions of dollars in daily commerce.

A Chronology of Legal Escalation

The legal history of this dispute has unfolded rapidly, reflecting the high stakes for both the retail and banking industries:

  • Early 2024: The Illinois Interchange Fee Prohibition Act is passed, sparking immediate concern among national banking associations and credit union leagues.
  • Mid-2024: The American Bankers Association (ABA), the Illinois Bankers Association, America’s Credit Unions, and the Illinois Credit Union League file a joint lawsuit to challenge the IFPA, citing the doctrine of federal preemption.
  • June 2026: The Office of the Comptroller of the Currency (OCC) issues an interim final rule, affirming that federal law grants national banks the authority to set fees as part of their core banking powers, effectively preempting the state law. The NCUA follows with a mirroring rule for federal credit unions.
  • June 2026: A federal district court grants a permanent injunction against the enforcement of the IFPA regarding national banks, validating the OCC’s interpretation of federal authority.
  • September 2026: The federal court expands the scope of the injunction to include federal credit unions, solidifying the legal shield against the Illinois statute.
  • Late 2026: Nine merchant trade associations file dual lawsuits against the OCC and NCUA, seeking to vacate the federal preemption orders and reinstate the IFPA’s authority.

The Role of Federal Preemption in Banking

At the heart of the current litigation is the legal concept of federal preemption. Under the National Bank Act and the Federal Credit Union Act, federal regulators have long held the authority to set standards for federally chartered institutions, ensuring that these entities can operate uniformly across state lines. The OCC and NCUA argue that the IFPA essentially attempts to rewrite the terms of contracts between banks and merchants, which is an area reserved for federal oversight.

For the banking industry, the integrity of the payment system relies on predictability. If Illinois were permitted to restrict interchange fees on specific portions of a transaction, other states might follow suit with their own unique, localized carve-outs. This "patchwork" of state-level regulations would force financial institutions to build hundreds of different systems to calculate fees based on the geography of a transaction, leading to significant increases in operational costs and, inevitably, delays in transaction processing speeds.

Economic Data and Industry Perspectives

The debate over interchange fees—often called "swipe fees"—is rooted in the economics of payment processing. Interchange fees cover the costs associated with fraud protection, data security, and the real-time liquidity provided by card issuers. According to data from the Federal Reserve, the costs of maintaining a secure and instantaneous digital payment infrastructure have risen alongside the increasing complexity of cybersecurity threats.

Merchant associations contend that these fees have reached levels that disproportionately impact small businesses. Conversely, the banking lobby points out that the U.S. payment system is the most efficient and secure in the world, largely because of the investment fueled by the current fee structure. By seeking to strip fees from tax and tip amounts, the IFPA effectively seeks to subsidize retail operations at the expense of the institutional infrastructure that enables those very payments.

ABA comments on merchant groups' lawsuits against OCC, NCUA | ABA Banking Journal

Official Responses and the Stance of Co-Plaintiffs

The recent filings by the nine merchant trade associations have drawn sharp criticism from the banking industry. The American Bankers Association and its partners issued a robust statement, expressing disappointment in the move and reiterating their commitment to the national payments system.

"We’re disappointed but not surprised by the merchants’ lawsuits, which seek only to undermine the nation’s trusted and tested payments system," the co-plaintiffs noted. They further emphasized that the OCC and NCUA’s actions were not merely administrative choices, but necessary defenses of federal supremacy. "As one federal court has already determined, the OCC and NCUA acted to affirm the longstanding supremacy of federal law over intrusive state regulations like the IFPA and prevent a patchwork of conflicting state requirements that would create payment chaos and uncertainty."

Industry analysts observe that this reaction signals a long-term legal battle. The co-plaintiffs are not only defending their current revenue models but are also defending the fundamental principle that state legislatures cannot dictate the internal operations of federally chartered financial institutions.

Broader Implications for the U.S. Economy

The outcome of these lawsuits will have implications far beyond Illinois. If the courts were to rule in favor of the merchant associations, it would signal a major shift in the balance of power between state and federal financial regulators. A successful challenge to the OCC and NCUA’s preemption orders would embolden state legislatures to pursue more aggressive regulatory agendas regarding financial products and service fees.

Furthermore, the "payment chaos" mentioned by the banking groups is a real concern for technology providers. The modern payment ecosystem relies on automated systems that process transactions in milliseconds. Introducing variable, state-specific logic into these systems would require a massive overhaul of the digital infrastructure. Critics of the merchant-led lawsuit argue that such a change would not result in consumer savings, but rather in higher costs and increased technical friction, as banks would be forced to pass on the costs of compliance to their customers.

Looking Toward the Judiciary

As the case moves forward, the judiciary will be tasked with interpreting the extent of the "banking powers" granted by Congress. The court will need to determine whether the OCC and NCUA exceeded their statutory authority in issuing their preemption orders or if they acted within the scope of their mandate to ensure a functioning national economy.

For the merchant associations, the goal is to secure a ruling that validates the right of states to regulate the "commercial environment" within their borders. For the banking sector, the objective is to maintain the supremacy of federal law, which they argue is the only mechanism capable of sustaining a unified, high-speed, and secure payment network.

As this legal tug-of-war continues, the broader financial services industry remains in a state of watchful waiting. The eventual ruling will likely serve as a landmark precedent for the limits of state intervention in federal financial markets, potentially shaping the future of digital payments for years to come. Whether the U.S. payment system remains a standardized, national network or evolves into a fragmented collection of state-specific rules is the core question that now sits before the courts.

You may also like